Back

Why Your Google Ads Performance Max Campaign Is Bleeding Budget on YouTube and Display and How to Fix It

Written by Vivienne WangDigital Marketing Specialist

If your Google Ads leads or e-commerce sales have quietly dipped over the past few months while your daily ad spend remains maxed out, you are not alone.

Across recent Google Ads audits our team has conducted for New Zealand businesses, a clear pattern has emerged. Campaigns that were generating steady returns a year ago are suddenly struggling to hit their cost-per-acquisition targets. When we look under the hood, the culprit is almost always the same: an over-reliance on Performance Max (PMax) campaigns that have quietly shifted a huge portion of their budget away from high-intent Search and Shopping into low-converting YouTube, Display, and Discover placements.

For the past few years, many New Zealand digital agencies have treated Performance Max as a set-and-forget shortcut. They bundle all of a client's products, headlines, images, and audience signals into a single PMax campaign and let Google's algorithm decide where to spend the money.

While that hands-off approach sometimes worked when PMax first launched, recent shifts in how Google allocates multi-channel budgets have exposed the danger of giving an automated black box total control of your marketing budget.

This guide explains what has changed inside Performance Max, how you can check your own account in five minutes to see where your money is actually going, and how separating your campaigns back into controlled Search, Standard Shopping, and Demand Gen structures restores profitability.

What Changed With Performance Max in 2026?

To understand why performance has shifted, you first need to look at how Performance Max operates. Unlike a traditional Google Search campaign where your ads only appear when someone actively types in a keyword, a single PMax campaign buys ad inventory across six different Google channels simultaneously:

  1. Google Search
  2. Google Shopping
  3. YouTube (In-stream videos and YouTube Shorts)
  4. The Google Display Network (millions of third-party websites and mobile apps)
  5. Google Discover
  6. Gmail

Recently, paid search specialists worldwide began documenting a sharp behavioural shift in PMax's bidding algorithm. When search competition tightens or cost-per-click (CPC) rates rise on Google Search and Shopping, the PMax algorithm increasingly hunts for cheaper impressions elsewhere to hit its volume targets.

The cheapest inventory Google owns is on YouTube (particularly YouTube Shorts), Display, and Discover.

Recent discussions across the global paid search community on Reddit's r/PPC forum highlight accounts where PMax suddenly began routing 60% to 98% of the entire daily budget into YouTube and Display overnight, starving the Search and Shopping placements that actually generate revenue.

Why This Hits New Zealand Businesses Harder

This algorithmic shift is particularly damaging in the New Zealand market for two reasons:

  • Lower Conversion Data Density: Machine learning requires high conversion volume to make smart bidding decisions. A US retailer spending $100,000 a month feeds Google hundreds of daily transactions. A New Zealand business spending $2,000 to $8,000 a month generates far fewer conversions. When conversion volume is modest, PMax struggles to predict who will buy, so it falls back on buying cheap video views and display clicks across broad audiences.
  • Lazy Agency Setup: Because building granular Search, Shopping, and remarketing campaigns takes hours of manual work, many local agencies put 80% to 100% of their clients' budgets into PMax. Worse, they leave Auto-Generated Video and Final URL Expansion turned on, giving Google permission to scrape images off your website, turn them into slideshow videos, and run them on YouTube channels your buyers would never watch.

How to Diagnose If Your PMax Campaign Is Wasting Money (4-Step Check)

For years, Google hid channel-level spending data inside Performance Max, forcing specialists to use third-party tools like Mike Rhodes' open-source PMax script on GitHub just to see how much money was going to Display and YouTube.

Following sustained pressure from advertisers, Google finally rolled out native Channel Performance reporting and a Channel Performance timeline view inside the Google Ads dashboard.

If you are a business owner or marketing manager, you no longer need to take your agency's word for it. Log into your Google Ads account and run this four-step diagnostic check.

Step 1: Check Your Native Channel Performance Split

  1. Open your Google Ads account and select your Performance Max campaign.
  2. In the left-hand menu, navigate to Insights and reports and click Channel performance.
  3. Scroll past the visual chart at the top (which can be difficult to read at a glance) down to the Channel distribution table.
  4. Click Columns > Modify columns > Conversions and add Cost, Conv. value / cost (ROAS), and Cost / conv. to the table.

Look closely at the Cost column across Display, YouTube, and Discover compared to Search. Note that inside this table, Google splits traffic into Ads using product data (which are your Shopping and Dynamic Remarketing ads) and Ads using assets (which are your text, image, and video ads). If more than 25% to 30% of your budget is going into asset-based YouTube, Display, or Discover ads with zero or very expensive conversions, your campaign is bleeding money.

Step 2: Check If "Engaged-View" Conversions Are Inflating Your Report

When you challenge an agency on high YouTube spend inside PMax, they will often point to the conversions column and claim YouTube is generating sales.

Check how those conversions are counted. By default, PMax blends standard Click-Through Conversions with Engaged-View Conversions. An engaged-view conversion means a user watched 10 seconds of your YouTube ad (or scrolled past a Shorts video), did not click it, and later bought from your website after searching your brand name on Google. PMax gives YouTube the credit for that sale, which trains the algorithm to dump even more of your budget into video placements.

Step 3: Check for Brand Cannibalisation

Unless your agency has applied an Account-Level Brand Exclusion List, Performance Max will aggressively bid on people typing your exact business name into Google.

Because customers searching for your company name already intend to buy from you, those clicks convert at a massive return on ad spend. PMax blends that easy brand revenue together with its wasted Display and YouTube spend. On a high-level monthly report, a 4.0x overall ROAS looks healthy, hiding the reality that your brand searches achieved a 15.0x ROAS while the remaining 70% of your budget lost money on cold Display and YouTube traffic.

Step 4: Audit the PMax Placement Report for Junk Apps and Channels

To see the exact websites and YouTube channels where your ads appeared:

  1. Go to Insights and reports > Report editor.
  2. Open the predefined Performance Max campaigns placement report.
  3. Sort by Impressions.

In poorly managed accounts, we routinely find thousands of impressions served on toddlers' nursery rhyme YouTube channels, foreign-language blogs, and mobile gaming apps where users accidentally tap banner ads while trying to close a game screen.

Why Lead Generation Businesses Should Almost Never Rely on PMax Alone

While e-commerce stores have a product feed and real checkout dollar values to anchor the algorithm, service and B2B businesses rely on lead forms and phone calls.

Running an unfiltered Performance Max campaign for lead generation is one of the fastest ways to burn a marketing budget. When you tell PMax to get you as many form submissions as possible on a fixed budget, the algorithm quickly discovers that it can generate very cheap leads via the Google Display Network.

Within weeks, your inbox fills up with spam enquiries, bots, and people claiming they never filled out your form. Worse, every time one of those fake leads fires your Thank You page tracking pixel, Google's AI thinks it succeeded and buys even more Display traffic from the same spammy network.

How Adhesion Structures Google Ads for Control and Profit

At Adhesion, we do not treat Performance Max as an all-in-one replacement for skilled account management. When Google updated its auction rules so that Performance Max no longer automatically overrides Standard Shopping campaigns (meaning the campaign with the highest Ad Rank now wins the auction), it gave hands-on specialists the power to take back control.

While setting up and managing separate campaign types takes significantly more engineering hours behind the scenes than throwing everything into PMax, the return on ad spend is far more predictable. Here is the architecture we use for New Zealand businesses:

Granular Search Campaigns

They capture high-intent buyers actively searching for your service, category, or product.

They allow strict Exact and Phrase match control, weekly negative keyword scrubbing, custom ad copy per service, and no wasted spend on Display or YouTube.

Standard Shopping Campaigns

They drive core e-commerce revenue for high-margin and best-selling products.

They give us visibility into actual search terms, control over bidding priorities, and 100% assurance that your budget stays on the Shopping tab rather than leaking into video.

Controlled Performance Max

We use dynamic remarketing, product discovery, and scale once Search and Shopping are maxed out.

The setup is stripped of junk assets, protected by brand exclusions, and segmented by product profit margins so it supports your core campaigns rather than cannibalising them.

Dedicated Demand Gen

We use targeted visual remarketing and upper-funnel awareness across YouTube, Discover, and Gmail.

Instead of PMax spraying random auto-generated videos across YouTube, we control the exact budget, audience segments, and placement formats.

5 Immediate Fixes If Your PMax Campaign Is Underperforming

If you run the diagnostic steps above and discover your Performance Max campaign is wasting budget on non-performing channels, here are five practical steps you or your agency should take immediately:

  1. Apply Account-Level Brand Exclusions: Go to Campaign settings > Brand exclusions and exclude your own company and brand names from PMax. Move your brand keywords into a dedicated, low-cost Standard Search campaign so you can measure true new-customer acquisition accurately.
  2. Lock Down Content Suitability and Placement Exclusions: Navigate to Tools > Content suitability. Exclude mobile app categories, parked domains, sensitive content labels, and add an account-level placement exclusion list to block children's YouTube channels and clickbait sites.
  3. Turn Off Auto-Generated Videos and Final URL Expansion: Inside your PMax campaign settings, disable automatically created video assets and restrict URL expansion so Google cannot send paid traffic to your blog posts, privacy policy, or About Us page.
  4. Test a Feed-Only PMax Structure or Shift to Standard Shopping: For e-commerce stores where PMax refuses to stop spending on Display and YouTube, removing text, image, and video assets from a new asset group forces the campaign to run strictly on your Google Merchant Center product feed (Shopping and dynamic remarketing). Better yet, shift your top-performing product categories into a dedicated Google Shopping campaign where you control the exact search queries.
  5. Feed the Algorithm Offline Conversion Tracking (OCT): If you run lead generation campaigns, stop optimising for basic form submissions. Connect your CRM to Google Ads so the algorithm only optimises toward leads that your sales team marks as qualified or closed-won.

Suspect Your Agency Has Put Your Account on Set-and-Forget Performance Max?

If your monthly reports look fine on paper while your actual enquiries or sales have slowed down, let our senior Auckland specialists take an objective look under the hood.

Adhesion is a certified Google Premier Partner

At Adhesion, we have been helping New Zealand businesses grow through paid search for over 18 years. We are a tight-knit Auckland agency which means you get direct access to the experts actually running your account. We believe in complete transparency: no hidden fees, no smoke and mirrors, and you always retain ownership of your data.

Whether you need a one-off campaign audit or full-service Google Ads management, contact us today for a no-obligation consultation.

Google Premier Partner

No obligation. Avg. response 3 hrs.

Stop losing leads to your competitors / wasting ad spend.